Searching for i-Good Lemmas to Accelerate Safety Model Checking

IC3/PDR and its variants have been the prominent approaches to safety model checking in recent years. Compared to the previous model-checking algorithms like BMC (Bounded Model Checking) and IMC (Interpolation Model Checking), IC3/PDR is attractive due to its completeness (vs. BMC) and scalability (vs. IMC). IC3/PDR maintains an over-approximate state sequence for proving the correctness. Although the sequence refinement methodology is known to be crucial for performance, the literature lacks a systematic analysis of the problem. We propose an approach based on the definition of i- good lemmas, and the introduction of two kinds of heuristics, i.e., branching and refer-skipping, to steer the search towards the construction of i-good lemmas. The approach is applicable to IC3 and its variant CAR (Complementary Approximate Reachability), and it is very easy to integrate within existing systems. We implemented the heuristics into two open-source model checkers, IC3Ref and SimpleCAR, as well as into the mature nuXmv platform, and carried out an extensive experimental evaluation on HWMCC benchmarks. The results show that the proposed heuristics can effectively compute more i-good lemmas, and thus improve the performance of all the above checkers.